Why a Golf Course Fight in Texas Could Rewrite Property Rights

Why a Golf Course Fight in Texas Could Rewrite Property Rights

Can a city take your land, hand the keys to a private operator, and call it a public park? That's the exact question heading before the Supreme Court of Texas in a high-stakes eminent domain fight over a 3.548-acre parcel in Westworth Village.

Back in 2021, Westworth Village offered property owner Jim Burgess $1.1 million for his land as part of a golf course redevelopment plan. When talks didn't land a deal, condemnation proceedings followed. A panel of three special commissioners pegged the property's value at $1.545 million. After Burgess challenged that valuation and lost his initial challenge to the taking in trial court, a jury later awarded him $1,313,675. Still, Burgess refused to treat condemnation as a done deal and appealed the taking itself. Recently making news in related news: Capsizing Survivability and Predator Dynamics When Eleven Remain Missing.

In June 2025, the Second Court of Appeals in Fort Worth sided with Burgess, reversing the trial court and handing landowners a major appellate victory. Now, after granting review in October 2026 in Case No. 25-0836, the Supreme Court of Texas is stepping in, with oral arguments scheduled for January 11, 2027.

How a Local Land Dispute Became a Statewide Test of Eminent Domain

On paper, 3.548 acres looks small. In Texas property law, it's a powder keg. Further insights regarding the matter are explored by NBC News.

Municipalities routinely run public parks and recreation facilities. Nobody blinks when a city builds a municipal pool or neighborhood trail that stays under public control. Where things get messy—and where eminent domain collides with commercial management—is when a city acquires land for a golf facility intended to be operated by a private business.

From a city council's perspective, bringing in a private operator can sound practical. Golf courses are expensive to maintain, tough to budget, and tricky to run day-to-day. Partnering with a commercial operator lets a municipality pitch a polished amenity without taking on every operational headache itself.

Honestly, though, calling a project a "public amenity" doesn't settle the constitutional math. Voters and lawmakers in Texas have spent years building guardrails around eminent domain precisely because government agencies and private developers often see "public benefit" through very different lenses.

What the Fort Worth Appeals Court Actually Said

When the Second Court of Appeals issued its opinion on June 19, 2025, the three-judge panel—Justices Mike Wallach, Elizabeth Kerr, and Brian Walker—didn't waffle. Justice Wallach wrote that courts must carefully scrutinize eminent domain authority, noting that condemnation is an area where the government must turn sharp corners and stay in its lane.

The appellate court reversed and remanded the case, pushing back against the idea that a public-facing recreation label automatically validates taking private land for a facility leased or run by a private operator. The ruling also left Westworth Village on the hook for court costs, which the city contested alongside its challenge to the merits.

What makes this opinion sting for local governments is how it frames the threshold question. It's not just about whether the check clears or whether a jury sets a fair price. It's about whether the government had the legal authority to force the sale in the first place.

What People Get Wrong About Condemnation and Private Operators

Whenever a headline mentions eminent domain, people tend to jump straight to two oversimplified ideas. Both miss how these fights actually play out in court.

Myth One: "A Jury Payout Means the Taking Was Legal"

A lot of folks assume that once a valuation panel or jury sets a dollar figure—like the $1.3 million-plus award in Burgess's case—the property dispute is basically over. Wrong. Compensation and authority are separate legal hurdles.

Even if a landowner gets a substantial valuation award, a court can still find that the condemnation itself exceeded constitutional or statutory boundaries. Fighting valuation is about how much you're paid if the land goes; fighting authority is about whether the government can force you to sell at all.

Myth Two: "Public Access Automatically Makes It a Public Use"

Cities frequently argue that if the public can use a park, trail, or recreational facility, the project serves a public purpose. That argument gets much trickier when a private commercial entity operates the facility or profits from it.

Courts look closely at structure, control, and statutory limits—not just marketing language. Slapping a public-recreation label onto a project involving private operation invites intense judicial pushback.

Why This Eminent Domain Battle Matters Beyond Westworth Village

If you don't live in Westworth Village or play golf, you might wonder why this docket deserves your attention. Because precedent doesn't stay put.

Across Texas, cities regularly weigh public-private partnerships, sports complexes, entertainment districts, and mixed-use recreational projects. A Supreme Court ruling in City of Westworth Village v. Jim Burgess will give municipal attorneys, developers, and property owners a much sharper map of what's allowed.

  • If the Supreme Court upholds the appellate approach: Cities will face tighter limits when condemning land for facilities run by private operators, forcing local officials to rely more heavily on voluntary purchases, negotiated leases of existing public land, or redesigns that don't require forced takings.
  • If the Supreme Court reverses: Municipalities could gain broader breathing room to use condemnation for recreational projects involving private operators, provided they satisfy statutory and constitutional standards—a prospect that makes property-rights advocates nervous.

At the same time, there's a real tension in local governance. Cities have to balance taxpayer budgets, aging infrastructure, and community amenities, while landowners have a right to expect strict adherence to constitutional limits. Reasonable people can debate where the policy sweet spot sits, which is exactly why appellate courts treat eminent domain with skepticism.

Practical Lessons From Watching Condemnation Fights

Having followed land-use and condemnation disputes closely, I've noticed a few mistakes landowners and local officials repeatedly make when tensions flare over a parcel:

  1. Treating early offers as final: An initial offer—whether $1.1 million or any other figure—is just the opening move in a much longer legal and financial process.
  2. Conflating price fights with authority fights: Hiring an appraiser only addresses value; challenging whether the government has power to condemn requires a distinct legal strategy from day one.
  3. Underestimating timeline drag: A dispute that starts with an offer in 2021 can easily stretch past 2026 and into 2027 oral arguments. Patience and clear documentation matter just as much as courtroom arguments.

What to Watch and Do Next

With the Supreme Court of Texas set to hear oral arguments on January 11, 2027, keep an eye on the briefing in Case No. 25-0836—especially how the justices question the line between public recreation and private operation. You can track docket updates and filings directly through the Supreme Court of Texas.

If you own property in Texas and receive an initial purchase inquiry or condemnation notice from a city or other condemning authority, don't sign away rights out of intimidation or rush to cash a check without understanding your options. Pull your property records, review any written offers carefully, and consult an experienced Texas eminent domain attorney before deadlines pass.

KF

Kenji Flores

Kenji Flores has built a reputation for clear, engaging writing that transforms complex subjects into stories readers can connect with and understand.